Ultimate Ranks

Home Movies Sherlock, Jr.

Sherlock, Jr. 1924

Directed by Buster Keaton

All-time standing

#158 of 4,399

In the top 4% of movies

By scope

1920s #11 of 92 Top 10% 1924 #2 of 10 Top 20%

Ballots (36)

All time 34

Rolling Stone

  • Published 2005
  • All-time list
  • Ranked #17
Read the source list
Toronto International Film Festival

Toronto International Film Festival

  • Published 2009
  • All-time list
  • Ranked #31
Read the source list

Village Voice

  • Published 1999
  • All-time list
  • Ranked #42
Read the source list
Sight & Sound

Sight & Sound

  • Published 2022
  • All-time list
  • Ranked #56
Read the source list
The Cinematheque

The Cinematheque

  • Published 2005
  • All-time list
  • Ranked #100
Read the source list
Halliwell's

Halliwell's

  • Published 2005
  • All-time list
  • Ranked #1017
Read the source list
LaCinetek

LaCinetek

  • Published 2025
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
LaCinetek

LaCinetek

  • Published 2022
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
LaCinetek

LaCinetek

  • Published 2021
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
LaCinetek

LaCinetek

  • Published 2020
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
LaCinetek

LaCinetek

  • Published 2016
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Steven Jay Schneider

Steven Jay Schneider

  • Published 2016
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Kino Muzeum

Kino Muzeum

  • Published 2015
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
LaCinetek

LaCinetek

  • Published 2015
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Cinemanía

Cinemanía

  • Published 2012
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Filmspotting

Filmspotting

  • Published 2012
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
The Independent

The Independent

  • Published 2009
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
David Thomson

David Thomson

  • Published 2008
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Steadycam

Steadycam

  • Published 2007
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked

Time

  • Published 2005
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Read the source list
Total Film

Total Film

  • Published 2005
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Jonathan Rosenbaum

Jonathan Rosenbaum

  • Published 2004
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Read the source list
Senses of Cinema

Senses of Cinema

  • Published 2004
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Senses of Cinema

Senses of Cinema

  • Published 2003
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Senses of Cinema

Senses of Cinema

  • Published 2002
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Senses of Cinema

Senses of Cinema

  • Published 2001
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Associated Press

Associated Press

  • Published 2000
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Senses of Cinema

Senses of Cinema

  • Published 2000
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Premiere

Premiere

  • Published 1998
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Read the source list
Movieline

Movieline

  • Published 1995
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Read the source list
Dirigido Por

Dirigido Por

  • Published 1992
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Danny Peary

Danny Peary

  • Published 1986
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Read the source list
Edições Cinematógrafo

Edições Cinematógrafo

  • Published 1982
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
R.A.E. Pickard

R.A.E. Pickard

  • Published 1971
  • All-time list
  • Included, unranked
Read the source list

Decade 2

1920s

Paste Magazine

  • Published 1929
  • Decade list · 1920s
  • Included, unranked

1900-1999

Village Voice

  • Published 2000
  • Decade list · 1900-1999
  • Ranked #42
Read the source list
Track your progress through the rankings